Miscommunication
“Don’t be wrong. I’m not suggesting we wear those weird chastity rings you know American kids have — you know, ‘We’re not shagging ’cause we’re mentals.’” -Being Human
Every once in a while, I like to have a sandwich of chunky peanut butter and thin-sliced smoked turkey on whole wheat bread. It’s not what you’d call regal, but it’s salty with an interesting mix of textures. Imagine if a national chain of restaurants not only offered that dish but sold it as a sweet dessert, and you might have an idea why Adventureland grossed just over $16 million at the box office.
Advertised as a film “from the [noun] of Superbad, Adventureland very quickly reveals that its attempts at raucous comedy have been segregated to the margins. The few people who saw it in theaters received many fewer dick and fart jokes per dollar than they’d been led to expect.
Of course, lacking lewd humor doesn’t necessarily relegate a movie to mediocrity. The Shawshank Redemption did all right without any hyperbolic elucidations on penis size. No one’s going to accuse Adventureland of aspiring to Shawshank, but it does succeed within its genre.
“Just what genre is that?” you ask? Think intentionally muddled comedic romance in which a rather directionless recent college graduate returns to his childhood home and attaches to a previously unknown woman who is both petit and possessing of artfully-shaped zygomatic bones. If some part of that sentence couldn’t also describe Garden State, then that’s an oversight on my part. They’re not the same movie; Adventureland involves both more ethical quandary and less silent velcro than does Garden State. They do, however, share a very concise narrative space.
One area in which Adventureland shines is its casting. Like a championship team comprised solely of role players, the picture places character actors in their proper places. Much as he did in Rodger Dodger, The Squid and the Whale, and the unfortunately short-lived Get Real, Jesse Eisenberg plays a conspicuously academic and neurotic naif. Drawing on her experiences from In the Land of Women and the dreadful Twilight series, Kristen Stewart continues to professionally portray the distressed damsels of cliche fame, in all of her impotent, brooding humorlessness. Ryan Reynolds is an unapologetic tool with texture; don’t pretend to be surprised. Of course, if you haven’t seen Party Down, then the amusement lent by Martin Starr might convince you to do so. Saturday Night Live cast members continue to confuse awkwardness with humor, but in this case, the jokes hit more often than not.
In fact, considering its meandering script and efficient use of cost-effective talent, one wonders why Adventureland was made as a feature film rather than a marginal series along the lines of Freaks and Geeks. As it stands, the picture is an adequate, nostalgic coming-of-age story with a disturbingly contrived conclusion. Formulation as a series would’ve allowed for further development of both plot lines and characters that suffered peripheral neglect in the cut to 107 minutes. It also would’ve allowed for a more acceptable ending. I seek denouement as much as the next guy, but it’s got to rise to meet the first two acts.